Skip to content
clever legalClaims & Compensation

Can You Claim Future Care Costs in a Medical Negligence Claim in Victoria?

What counts as future care, how the need is proved, how unpaid family care is limited, how the lump sum is discounted, and what the NDIS and Medicare may take back.

The short answer

Yes. In Victoria you can claim the reasonable cost of the care, treatment and support you will need in future because of the negligence, including care your family gives you for free.

General information only — this article is not legal advice.

That covers paid carers and nursing, domestic help, future medical and rehabilitation costs, and equipment or changes the injury makes necessary. The test is what is reasonable to repair the consequences of the injury, and because the costs have not been spent yet, they are proved with medical, care and cost evidence rather than receipts. Unpaid family care is limited by sections 28IA and 28IB of the Wrongs Act 1958 (Vic): the care must be reasonably needed solely because of the injury, it is not compensated if it is both under 6 hours a week and under 6 months, and its rate is capped by reference to Victorian average weekly earnings. A lump sum for future costs is reduced to its present value under section 28I. The significant-injury threshold does not apply to any of these costs.

This guide goes deeper on that one part of a claim: what counts as future care, how the need is proved, how the lump sum is worked out, and whether the NDIS or Medicare can take some of it back. It covers Victoria. For every kind of loss a claim can include, see what compensation you can claim for medical negligence. For how past costs differ from estimated ones, see general vs special damages.

  What it covers Limits under the Wrongs Act Evidence it turns on
Paid care Carers, nursing, personal care and domestic help you will have to pay for Must be a reasonable response to the injury; lump sum discounted under s 28I A care needs assessment, treating doctors’ opinions, quotes from providers
Unpaid family care Help from family or friends who are not paid for it Reasonable need arising solely from the injury, a minimum of hours and duration, and a rate cap (ss 28IA, 28IB) A record of who helps and for how long, statements from carers, a care needs assessment
Future treatment Surgery, medication, therapy and rehabilitation you will still need Must be caused by the injury and reasonable; lump sum discounted under s 28I Treating and independent medical opinion on your prognosis
Equipment and changes Aids and equipment, and changes to your home or vehicle the injury makes necessary Must be a reasonable response to the injury; lump sum discounted under s 28I An assessment of what you need, such as one by an occupational therapist, and quotes

Section numbers are from the Wrongs Act 1958 (Vic), authorised version 130. No dollar figures are published here, because the care rate cap moves with average weekly earnings.

What future care costs can you claim?

Compensation is meant to put you, as far as money can, in the position you would have been in if the negligence had not happened. The High Court restated that starting point in Stewart v Metro North Hospital and Health Service [2025] HCA 34, a case about the cost of future care. If the injury means you will need help or treatment you would not otherwise have needed, the reasonable cost of it can form part of the claim.

The Wrongs Act describes attendant care as services of a domestic nature, services relating to nursing, and services that aim to ease the consequences of an injury (s 28B). Within that, a claim for future care and related costs can include:

  • paid carers, nursing and help with personal care
  • domestic help, such as cleaning and cooking you can no longer do
  • future medical, hospital, medication, therapy and rehabilitation costs
  • equipment and aids, which the Health Complaints Commissioner lists as special equipment
  • changes to your home or vehicle, or a different place to live, where the injury makes them reasonably necessary
  • travel and accommodation for future treatment

These are all economic losses. Past costs are proved with receipts. Future ones are estimated, which is why the evidence behind them matters so much.

Related guide What Compensation Can You Recover for Medical Negligence? 6 min · Updated 26 Sep 2026

Can you choose to be cared for at home rather than in a facility?

You can claim the cost of care at home if that choice is a reasonable way to deal with the consequences of the injury. That is the effect of Stewart v Metro North Hospital and Health Service [2025] HCA 34.

In that case, an injured man was being cared for in an institution and wanted damages for the cost of nursing and medical care in a home of his own. The trial judge and the Queensland Court of Appeal weighed the health benefit of living at home against its higher cost and refused the extra amount. The High Court unanimously held that this approach was wrong. Reasonableness is not decided by balancing health benefits against cost alone, and the injured person’s choice to live at home was an important factor.

Once the injured person shows the choice was reasonable, the burden moves to the defendant. It has to show that some or all of the cost could have been avoided by an alternative that the injured person unreasonably refused. In that case, it had not. The decision is from the High Court, so Victorian courts apply it to the common law of damages.

Can you claim for care your family gives you for free?

Yes, within limits set by the Wrongs Act. The Act calls this gratuitous attendant care: care provided to you that you have not paid for and are not liable to pay for (s 28B).

Under section 28IA, no damages may be awarded for that care unless the court is satisfied of three things:

  • there is, or was, a reasonable need for the care
  • the need arose solely because of the injury
  • the care would not be provided to you but for the injury

Section 28IA also rules out damages where the care is provided for less than 6 hours a week and for less than 6 months. On its words, that bar applies only when both are true.

Section 28IB caps the amount. If the care is provided for 40 hours a week or more, damages cannot exceed, for each week, the average weekly total earnings of all employees in Victoria as estimated by the Australian Statistician. If it is less than 40 hours a week, the cap is an hourly rate of one-fortieth of that amount. The figure changes as the Statistician’s estimates change, so we do not publish it.

The damages are awarded to you, not to the person caring for you. A simple record of who helps you, what they do and for how many hours each week makes this part of a claim much easier to prove.

Can you claim if you can no longer care for your children or others?

Possibly. Section 28ID lets a court award damages for the loss of your capacity to provide unpaid care to your dependants. Dependants are people wholly, mainly or partly dependent on you when the negligence happened, and children not yet born at that time who are born later (s 28B).

The court must be satisfied that:

  • for existing dependants, you provided the care before the negligence happened
  • your dependants cannot provide the care themselves because of their age or a physical or mental incapacity
  • but for the injury, you would reasonably have been expected to provide the care for at least 6 hours a week, for at least 6 consecutive months
  • the care will be needed for those hours and that period, and that need is reasonable

The same average-weekly-earnings cap applies (s 28IE), and this loss cannot also be included in damages for pain and suffering (s 28ID(3)).

How are future care needs proved?

Because nothing has been spent yet, the need is proved with evidence about you. Section 28IA requires the court to be satisfied that unpaid care is reasonably needed, and paid care has to be a reasonable response to the injury. Both depend on evidence such as:

  • your treating doctors’ records and opinions about your prognosis
  • reports from independent medical experts
  • an assessment of the care, equipment and changes you need, such as one by an occupational therapist
  • quotes or price lists from care providers and suppliers
  • statements from the family members who care for you

The estimate also has to cover how long you will need the care. That turns on the medical evidence about your condition, so it is assessed for each person rather than taken from a table.

How is a lump sum for future care worked out?

Damages for the future are usually assessed as a single lump sum. Because you receive money now for costs that fall due over many years, the law reduces it to what those future costs are worth today.

Section 28I of the Wrongs Act fixes how that is done. Where an award includes a lump sum for economic loss referable to the future, its present value is worked out using a discount rate of 5 per cent, unless regulations prescribe a different percentage. Future care, future treatment and future equipment are economic loss, so the same rate applies to them as to future lost earnings.

How the other caps and thresholds shape the overall amount is set out in how much compensation for medical negligence in Victoria.

Do you need a significant injury to claim future care costs?

No. Section 28LE of the Wrongs Act bars damages for non-economic loss unless the injury is a significant injury. Non-economic loss means pain and suffering, loss of amenities of life and loss of enjoyment of life (s 28B). Future care, treatment and equipment are economic loss, so the threshold does not apply to them.

Whether a claim made up mostly of these costs is worth bringing is a separate question, because proving negligence costs money. Our guide on whether a claim is too small walks through how to think about that.

Do you have to pay back NDIS or Medicare from a settlement?

Amounts already paid can be. Two Commonwealth laws let the government recover past payments from a judgment or settlement.

Medicare. Under section 8 of the Health and Other Services (Compensation) Act 1995 (Cth), if compensation is fixed by a judgment or settlement, an amount equal to the Medicare benefits already paid for treatment of the injury, or as a result of it, is payable to the Commonwealth. You are the one who owes it (s 8(4)). It is reduced if liability was shared with you (s 8(2)). Section 10 does the same for residential care subsidy or home care subsidy already paid. These rules do not apply where the entire compensation is a small amount, which section 38 sets at $5,000 unless regulations prescribe a higher amount.

NDIS. Under section 107 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth), if a settlement or consent judgment fixes compensation for an injury that caused your impairment to any extent, an amount equal to the NDIS amounts already paid for supports for that impairment is payable by you to the National Disability Insurance Agency. It is reduced if liability was shared, and it cannot exceed what is left of the compensation after amounts such as Medicare are repaid. Section 106 applies a similar rule to a judgment after a trial, limited to the part of the award the judgment specifies for supports of the kind the NDIS funds. The amount is a debt to the Agency (s 108).

The Agency can also give the defendant or its insurer a notice that it proposes to recover the amount directly (s 111). While that notice has effect, they are not liable to pay the compensation to you (s 112). And if you are a participant who has taken no reasonable action to claim compensation, the Agency can require you to (s 104).

Future NDIS support is a separate question. The Act allows NDIS rules to set how lump-sum compensation that includes an amount for supports is taken into account when your NDIS funding is worked out (ss 32K(4) and 35(4)).

Worth knowing: these repayments come out of a settlement, so they matter when any offer is being weighed. If you receive NDIS support, raise it early.

How do you find out what future care your claim could include?

What a future care claim could include depends on the medical evidence about your injury and the help you need now. Claims also have strict deadlines; see time limits for medical negligence claims. If you want someone to look at yours, start a free assessment. We will tell you plainly where you stand. There is no obligation, and no outcome is guaranteed.

Common questions

Can family members be paid for caring for you after medical negligence?

The damages are awarded to you, not to them, but the value of their unpaid care can form part of your claim. Under sections 28IA and 28IB of the Wrongs Act 1958 (Vic), the care must be reasonably needed solely because of the injury, it is not compensated if it is both under 6 hours a week and under 6 months, and its rate is capped by reference to Victorian average weekly earnings.

Is a future care award reduced to present value?

Yes. Under section 28I of the Wrongs Act 1958 (Vic), a lump sum for future economic loss, including future care, is reduced to its present value using a discount rate of 5 per cent, unless regulations prescribe a different rate.

Do you need a significant injury to claim future care costs?

No. The significant-injury threshold in section 28LE of the Wrongs Act 1958 (Vic) applies only to non-economic loss such as pain and suffering. Future care, treatment and equipment are economic loss, so they can be claimed whether or not the threshold is met.

Do you have to repay the NDIS from a medical negligence settlement?

You may. Under section 107 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth), if a settlement fixes compensation for an injury that caused your impairment, NDIS amounts already paid for supports for that impairment become payable to the Agency, reduced if liability was shared.

Is Medicare paid back from a medical negligence settlement?

Generally, yes. Under section 8 of the Health and Other Services (Compensation) Act 1995 (Cth), Medicare benefits already paid for treatment of the injury are repayable to the Commonwealth from a judgment or settlement. Section 38 waives this where the entire compensation is a small amount.

Sources